Discussion on Military Orders and Political Commentary
Dec, 5 2025
The video, which included six Democratic lawmakers, emphasized the importance of conscience in military service, particularly in the context of potential illegal orders from the Trump administration. Hostin attempted to counter Smith's argument by referencing past statements from Pete Hegseth, a former Secretary of War, who had also suggested that military personnel should not follow unlawful orders. Smith dismissed Hegseth's qualifications and maintained his stance against Kelly's comments.
During the discussion, Hostin pointed out that Kelly's message was aligned with military code, which allows for the refusal of illegal orders. Smith acknowledged this but reiterated his concern about the implications of Kelly's position, particularly for those with military backgrounds. The exchange highlighted differing perspectives on the responsibilities of military personnel in relation to political directives and the potential consequences of disobeying orders.
The debate reflects broader issues regarding the intersection of military ethics, political accountability, and the role of public figures in shaping discourse around these topics.