PHOENIX, Ariz. – The AmericaFest 2025 event, organized by Turning Point USA, revealed notable divisions within the conservative movement. Erika Kirk, a prominent leader in the organization, emphasized her role as a mother during her address. Key conservative figures, including Ben Shapiro and Tucker Carlson, engaged in disagreements primarily focused on topics such as Israel and the concept of 'heritage Americans.'

Vivek Ramaswamy, a candidate for Ohio governor, expressed skepticism regarding the idea of 'heritage Americans,' advocating for the view that all individuals who adhere to U.S. laws should be regarded as equally American. This perspective reflects ongoing debates within conservative circles about identity politics and the implications of lineage in defining American identity.

Attendees, including a fourth-generation farmer from South Dakota, voiced a preference for prioritizing economic issues over identity disputes. The farmer highlighted the impact of tariffs on his agricultural business while maintaining a long-term optimistic outlook.

Kirk acknowledged the necessity of these discussions within the conservative movement as they prepare for the upcoming midterm elections. A spokesperson for Turning Point USA emphasized the importance of engaging in uncomfortable debates to build a cohesive coalition. The event concluded with anticipation for a speech by Vice President JD Vance, as attendees reflected on the need for unity despite evident divisions. Representative Anna Paulina Luna from Florida reminded the audience of the collective stakes involved, suggesting that internal conflicts must be resolved to effectively counter perceived threats from the political left.

In a related context, Jennifer Welch, a left-wing podcaster, has called for progressives to boycott CBS News following the network's airing of a town hall featuring Erika Kirk. During the event, Kirk addressed the assassination of her husband, Charlie Kirk, and criticized those who justified the act. Welch expressed concern that CBS is shifting towards a propaganda model, neglecting significant issues such as economic burdens and healthcare crises affecting working-class Americans.

Welch emphasized the need for collective action against corporate media practices that prioritize sensationalism over substantive journalism. She argued that CBS's focus on the Kirk town hall detracts from pressing societal challenges, including inflation and healthcare access. The incident has sparked discussions about the role of media in shaping public discourse and the responsibilities of news organizations to their audiences. Welch's call for a boycott underscores a growing sentiment among some progressives that media accountability is essential for fostering a more equitable and informed society.